Mafia XVIII: Return of the Roman Numerals: D6: Scum keep tub

Godders · **Posted:** May 6th, 2012, 4:03 pm

If i was Mafia, why the hell would i go and pretend like you were the real Mafia, i am sure it would probably be much easier to say that Aragorn was Mafia than you.

I'm sure if Aragorn was Mafia he would've killed me off earlier knowing i was a detective than using me to his advtange. (I'm not really sure i haven't seen him play before and imagine that he is a little rusty)

Scar · **Posted:** May 6th, 2012, 4:22 pm

Godders wrote:

If i was Mafia, why the hell would i go and pretend like you were the real Mafia, i am sure it would probably be much easier to say that Aragorn was Mafia than you.

I'm sure if Aragorn was Mafia he would've killed me off earlier knowing i was a detective than using me to his advtange. (I'm not really sure i haven't seen him play before and imagine that he is a little rusty)

You would target me because Tahu and Aragorn havn't been very active this game really until yesterday. So you felt it would be easier to paint me as Mafia to two people who havn't been participating a whole lot in the game than it would be to convince me that Aragorn was Mafia, especially after I pushed against you at the start of the day and you got a villager killed yesterday.

Exactly, if Aragorn or I were Mafia you wouldn't have lasted this long if you really were a Detective. But as you aren't a real Detective, and in reality are Mafia you have lived this long. I don't think I can remember more than one or two games I have ever played or seen played where the Detective lived this long. The fact of the matter is our Detective died yesterday because of your false claims.

Godders · **Posted:** May 6th, 2012, 4:29 pm

I lived this long because most days key players in Mafia eyes popped up like Dr Henry, Landerpurex etc and i'm sure if this game went onto another night then i would imagine i would be kept alive because i am the most easily lynchable, and i would only imagine Aragorn would be killed because Tahu seems to be on your side.

Scar · **Posted:** May 6th, 2012, 5:03 pm

Godders wrote:

I lived this long because most days key players in Mafia eyes popped up like Dr Henry, Landerpurex etc and i'm sure if this game went onto another night then i would imagine i would be kept alive because i am the most easily lynchable, and i would only imagine Aragorn would be killed because Tahu seems to be on your side.

No, again you've lived this long because you are the one doing the killing. Detectives always take priority over normal Villagers. We saw this last night, Henry was killed while a self-proclaimed Detective is left to live another night, so if you really were a Detective and not a Mafia member you'd be gone already.

Furthermore, while Henry was still alive he was certain that you and Top were the two remaining Mafia. He was right about Top, and you've done nothing at all to make me believe he was wrong about you.

Aragorn Ix · **Posted:** May 6th, 2012, 5:38 pm

I think Scar has it right Godders

Sighence · **Posted:** May 6th, 2012, 6:27 pm

Oh my.

Godders, Scrubbing Bubble Detective, has been popped.

Night 5, 48 hours, go.

Sighence · **Posted:** May 6th, 2012, 7:05 pm

Day 6 has arrived.

Aragorn, Scrubbing Bubble, has been popped.

The bathtub scum still claims this area of porcelain.

Debrief to follow.

Scar · **Posted:** May 6th, 2012, 7:06 pm

i must say, I am awesome

Topsummoner · **Posted:** May 6th, 2012, 7:07 pm

gg noobs no re

more to come after debrief

Sighence · **Posted:** May 6th, 2012, 7:08 pm

(won't be for a few hours, feel free to discuss openly)

Dr Henry · **Posted:** May 6th, 2012, 7:27 pm

Scar wrote:

i must say, I am awesome

Not entirely. I had you pinned as the mafia, I had just hoped that by acting like I thought it was Godders, you'd have left me alive in the hopes that I'd get him lynched today. Backfired nicely though, since you used "Henry has been right about Kik and Top" to convince Aragorn and Tahu :/

Ah well, despite the utter mess that happened D2, was a fairly fun game. Guess Aragorn and I truely were the only vanilla townies - lame

Scar · **Posted:** May 6th, 2012, 8:01 pm

Eh, I foiled your plan which made any private suspicions you had against me irrelevant. And then even used what you'd said while you were alive to convince Aragorn to kill a guy who was confirming him as town and had helped kill Top.

I think that's awesome.

Topsummoner · **Posted:** May 6th, 2012, 8:02 pm

Godders wasn't confirming anyone. As should be obvious to everyone at this point, he was a Random Detective.

Market Man6 · **Posted:** May 6th, 2012, 9:05 pm

Well done scar.

*waiting to hear hosts response*

Saten Ruiko · **Posted:** May 6th, 2012, 10:23 pm

Nicely done; Scar had me convinced.

You deserve that win!

Kikori · **Posted:** May 6th, 2012, 10:37 pm

Remember, kids, MSN posts in a format of "Date, Time, Sender, Receiver, Message".

Hidden:

MSN wrote:

4/22/2012 12:30:41 PM Jeff James House So would townie-you realize that my roleclaim was based around the fact that Monk sent role PM's WELL AFTER the topic started?
4/22/2012 12:30:58 PM James House Jeff He did?
4/22/2012 12:31:00 PM Jeff James House Yes.
4/22/2012 12:31:03 PM James House Jeff I was one of the last people to see the topic
4/22/2012 12:31:10 PM James House Jeff Why would you not bring this up in your defense?
4/22/2012 12:31:11 PM Jeff James House Rex and I were able to make two posts each before getting our role PM.
4/22/2012 12:31:21 PM Jeff James House I thought it was common knowledge, and that you saw the post.
4/22/2012 12:31:22 PM Jeff James House posts.*
4/22/2012 12:31:29 PM Jeff James House Hell, Lander and I both commented on it on yahoo as well.
4/22/2012 12:31:33 PM Jeff James House Topic up, no PM sent.
4/22/2012 12:31:37 PM James House Jeff I did see the posts but I guess it kind of flew over my head.
4/22/2012 12:31:46 PM Jeff James House How delightfully scummy.
4/22/2012 12:31:50 PM Jeff James House Ignoring vital information. :weird:

4/22/2012 12:32:00 PM James House Jeff I legitimately missed it.
4/22/2012 12:32:08 PM James House Jeff Like why would I still be lying about that HERE?
4/22/2012 12:32:24 PM Jeff James House Because you're secretly the Usurper trying to get me killed.
4/22/2012 12:32:28 PM James House Jeff of course
4/22/2012 12:32:38 PM James House Jeff because you're secretly the godfather
4/22/2012 12:32:45 PM Jeff James House How'd you know?
4/22/2012 12:33:06 PM James House Jeff well the usurper wouldn't just be assigned a random mafia goon to usurp
4/22/2012 12:33:11 PM James House Jeff obviously there'd have to be a godfather too
4/22/2012 12:34:05 PM Jeff James House Well, the good news is the legit missing of post offers us a way out of our argument, without seeming to scummy.
4/22/2012 12:34:19 PM Jeff James House In my post I pointed out I claimed Vigilante, which is what I thought you were attacking me on anyway.
4/22/2012 12:34:28 PM Jeff James House "No, you claimed detective, back when you and Rex made your early posts."
4/22/2012 12:34:34 PM James House Jeff I was attacking you for your very first post.
4/22/2012 12:34:35 PM Jeff James House Legit finally see the late PM's.
4/22/2012 12:34:48 PM Jeff James House Ask if having no role was the basis for my posts / if they were a joke.
4/22/2012 12:34:51 PM Jeff James House Er.
4/22/2012 12:34:53 PM James House Jeff I see that now
4/22/2012 12:34:53 PM Jeff James House late
4/22/2012 12:34:55 PM James House Jeff >_>
4/22/2012 12:34:58 PM Jeff James House something.
4/22/2012 12:35:00 PM James House Jeff durr hurr
4/22/2012 12:35:00 PM Jeff James House I know what I wanted to say.
4/22/2012 12:35:02 PM James House Jeff anyways
4/22/2012 12:35:04 PM Jeff James House But not how to word it.
4/22/2012 12:35:05 PM James House Jeff go ahead and point that out to me
4/22/2012 12:36:41 PM James House Jeff absolutely ridiculous how you're taking my breaking of the quote as a scumtell though.
4/22/2012 12:37:57 PM Jeff James House Well, I assumed the entire argument was jokative.
4/22/2012 12:38:05 PM Jeff James House Since I thought you knew about Monk being late with the PMs.
4/22/2012 12:38:12 PM James House Jeff nope
4/22/2012 12:38:15 PM James House Jeff I didn't.
4/22/2012 12:38:32 PM James House Jeff I saw my PM
4/22/2012 12:38:35 PM James House Jeff the topic was already like
4/22/2012 12:38:37 PM James House Jeff 17 posts in
4/22/2012 12:38:39 PM James House Jeff so I caught up quickly
4/22/2012 12:38:50 PM James House Jeff so that I could make my obligatory joke-post on Lander
4/22/2012 12:38:58 PM James House Jeff I was hoping to beat him to the punch but it was not to be
4/22/2012 12:40:08 PM James House Jeff .... that was a filthy way of pointing out I missed it
4/22/2012 12:40:12 PM James House Jeff you posted like you already knew I missed it
4/22/2012 12:40:35 PM Jeff James House I did not. :?:

tactical omission
4/22/2012 12:48:47 PM James House Jeff so yeah
4/22/2012 12:48:51 PM James House Jeff I wasn't getting anything out of my system
4/22/2012 12:48:57 PM James House Jeff your post seemed legitimately scummy to me.
4/22/2012 12:51:25 PM James House Jeff hm

The entire "faked argument" that pinned me and Topsummoner as mafia was in fact a genuine misunderstanding. Kind of sucks that we ended up being called out on it at the very start, since we were both behaving as normally as possible (not counting me "attacking him for BBcode").

In the end, the plan worked. Once I realized how screwed I was, I had to at least get something rolling in our direction. I could have claimed Detective and said "I'm innocent and someone is lying about having investigating me", but. Two mafia claiming Doctor (which would normally never happen), with one of them actually being in a position to have his claim "validated"? I was a martyr, sure, but I had to go out swinging while securing Top for as long as possible. Market Man's sheer scummy behavior served me well. With a detective dead, I was soon to be taken out.
Henry was right about the day of my lynch passing too fast for the village to use. It was my one worry. "Tahu daykills Kikori, confirms the both of them and gives us a day to talk" couldn't happen. AND IT DIDN'T. IT FELT AWESOME.
Kudos to Scar for maintaining that perfect amount of distance and (dis)agreeability to finish the game off.

Scar · **Posted:** May 6th, 2012, 10:39 pm

Also, encase anyone was wondering. We just genuinely didn't send a kill PM on N1. Everyone thought everyone else was going to do it.

Landerpurex · **Posted:** May 6th, 2012, 11:45 pm

This game made me incredibly angry on several fronts. In the end, despite my role and my suspicions, it was a success for the mafia and that's all there is to it.

As a wise man once said, what you believe or know doesn't matter. The key is getting others to follow you.

Riptide · **Posted:** May 7th, 2012, 4:59 am

Some normal game this turned out to be...

Topsummoner wrote:

Godders wasn't confirming anyone. As should be obvious to everyone at this point, he was a Random Detective.

I eventually pointed this out before I got lynched... Anyways, good game Mafia.

Godders · **Posted:** May 7th, 2012, 5:29 am

My role as detective appeared to be sane except when examining myself where i came up Mafia.

Aragorn, why didn't you listen to me?!?! ;_;

Mafia XVIII: Return of the Roman Numerals: D6: Scum keep tub

Who is online