Upick Revengeance - GAME SET

Dr Henry · **Posted:** April 9th, 2014, 5:03 pm

SparkyAMS wrote:

I figured AC360 was a daytime detective/reporter, turns out it was just a hypocritical Anderson Cooper imitator on twitter.

Of course Ace could just be lying, and it might just be flavor text. Either way that would make you someone I do not trust.

Tennis Ace

Also last trial Jaron claimed to be mafia all game, and was not. Now he is vicariously living through a Ninja Mafia Leader, so I am not certain he is mafia. But there is really no way to know.

So you completely ignore me... and then vote for somebody because they roleclaim a perfectly plausible role to explain the flavour text which listed Bluecoat.

Now just to put it out there - I do not believe Tennis Ace when he says that all his role can do is write flavour text... but I don't think a host would ever tell us not to trust someone unless a role pushed him to. The unnecessary role-claim is also suspicious, but my vote remains squarely on Sparky.

Sighence · **Posted:** April 9th, 2014, 5:09 pm

bluecoat wrote:

[bSighence[/b], for trying too hard with the .gif and/or video posting.

Blue, don't be both Ashlee Simpson albums.

bluecoat · **Posted:** April 9th, 2014, 5:11 pm

I didn't move my vote because I'm still not sure about you.

Thr's only played a couple games to my knowledge; he was making a lot of the same mistakes I saw in FriskyAl, and they are things that get you lynched. I don't start trains on newer players this early in the game, but he needed the kick/advice.

Thr · **Posted:** April 9th, 2014, 5:21 pm

bluecoat wrote:

I didn't move my vote because I'm still not sure about you.

Thr's only played a couple games to my knowledge; he was making a lot of the same mistakes I saw in FriskyAl, and they are things that get you lynched. I don't start trains on newer players this early in the game, but he needed the kick/advice.

I'm not doing most of this by mistake, I have my own plans. Unless I don't time it right like last game. :awesome:

Tennis Ace · **Posted:** April 9th, 2014, 5:29 pm

Lol, I'm so getting night-killed tonight if people think there is an extra part to my role. I was hoping to have some sort of detective ability because Anderson Cooper is/was an investigative journalist, but I've explained the total extent of my role. It isn't that exciting, sadly.

Aragorn Ix · **Posted:** April 9th, 2014, 5:55 pm

Dr Henry wrote:

SparkyAMS wrote:

I figured AC360 was a daytime detective/reporter, turns out it was just a hypocritical Anderson Cooper imitator on twitter.

Of course Ace could just be lying, and it might just be flavor text. Either way that would make you someone I do not trust.

Tennis Ace

Also last trial Jaron claimed to be mafia all game, and was not. Now he is vicariously living through a Ninja Mafia Leader, so I am not certain he is mafia. But there is really no way to know.

So you completely ignore me... and then vote for somebody because they roleclaim a perfectly plausible role to explain the flavour text which listed Bluecoat.

Now just to put it out there - I do not believe Tennis Ace when he says that all his role can do is write flavour text... but I don't think a host would ever tell us not to trust someone unless a role pushed him to. The unnecessary role-claim is also suspicious, but my vote remains squarely on Sparky.

I'm inclined to agree with you regarding Sparky. Just throwing votes out with little rationalising is deeply suspicious.

Sighence · **Posted:** April 9th, 2014, 6:19 pm

Thr wrote:

I have my own plans.

Your own plans?

As in not-the-town's?

Thr

Thr · **Posted:** April 9th, 2014, 7:08 pm

Sighence wrote:

Thr wrote:

I have my own plans.

Your own plans?

As in not-the-town's?

Thr

If you want to pick at it that much it could also mean as in not the mafias. But if you want to vote for me with that reason I won't stop you.

Riptide · **Posted:** April 9th, 2014, 7:58 pm

Thr wrote:

Also I still think Aragon is probably mafia. I stated that above.

Misread that, thought you said you think he's townie.

Kikori · **Posted:** April 9th, 2014, 8:29 pm

bluecoat wrote:

I didn't move my vote because I'm still not sure about you.

Thr's only played a couple games to my knowledge; he was making a lot of the same mistakes I saw in FriskyAl, and they are things that get you lynched. I don't start trains on newer players this early in the game, but he needed the kick/advice.

Which is why you're now voting for one of two who are posting more pictures / videos than actual text without any visible thought toward the other. Certainly not wishy washy as could be about vote targets while being oddly satisfied with Thr's responses. Especially still thinking an almost completely confirmed person is still Mafia. :?:

Spirographed · **Posted:** April 9th, 2014, 8:40 pm

Thr wrote:

bluecoat wrote:

I didn't move my vote because I'm still not sure about you.

Thr's only played a couple games to my knowledge; he was making a lot of the same mistakes I saw in FriskyAl, and they are things that get you lynched. I don't start trains on newer players this early in the game, but he needed the kick/advice.

I'm not doing most of this by mistake, I have my own plans. Unless I don't time it right like last game. :awesome:

Obvious 3rd Party. Thr, because your agenda is of no use to the town and just plain complicates an already (obvIously) complicated game.

Tennis Ace · **Posted:** April 9th, 2014, 8:45 pm

Gonna go ahead and unvote and change to Sparky, since I support that lynch more than a Thr one.

Muscular Ape · **Posted:** April 9th, 2014, 8:47 pm

I am pretty sure Thr is alluding to his strategy of 'fishing' out mafia that he used two games ago. Funnily enough, in that game, it also made him seem very much like scum to me. He is pretty much playing the same way as he was in that game, where he ended up being town, which is why I'm not feeling it at the moment. Am I missing a subtle distinction?

Tennis Ace · **Posted:** April 9th, 2014, 8:49 pm

Sighence wrote:

Tennis Ace wrote:

I'm gonna come clean about my role as well, in an attempt to whittle down those who haven't said anything yet.

I'm essentially a vanilla townie. I'm Anderson Cooper. I can message Top anything up to 140 characters which will then be posted at the end of the day. My first message on day 1 was because I thought bluecoat seemed suspicious, but I hadn't mentioned him in any of my posts, so people wouldn't guess I was Anderson. There was nothing I wanted to say after day 2, and now that I have revealed my role, I don't really see a point in doing anymore AC360 messages since everyone would know it is me.

Don't think I don't know what else Anderson Cooper has done. I doubt that you weren't given other toys.

god im such a nerd

The Mole Season 2 is my favorite reality show of all time. I WISH I COULD TINY BUBBLES PEOPLE. And Heather is still my queen.

but I digress, lol.

SparkyAMS · **Posted:** April 9th, 2014, 8:50 pm

Dr Henry wrote:

SparkyAMS wrote:

I figured AC360 was a daytime detective/reporter, turns out it was just a hypocritical Anderson Cooper imitator on twitter.

Of course Ace could just be lying, and it might just be flavor text. Either way that would make you someone I do not trust.

Tennis Ace

Also last trial Jaron claimed to be mafia all game, and was not. Now he is vicariously living through a Ninja Mafia Leader, so I am not certain he is mafia. But there is really no way to know.

So you completely ignore me... and then vote for somebody because they roleclaim a perfectly plausible role to explain the flavour text which listed Bluecoat.

Now just to put it out there - I do not believe Tennis Ace when he says that all his role can do is write flavour text... but I don't think a host would ever tell us not to trust someone unless a role pushed him to. The unnecessary role-claim is also suspicious, but my vote remains squarely on Sparky.

Yes, I obviously have COMPLETELY IGNORED YOU by making a post dedicated to why I voted for Bluecoat.

"and then vote for somebody because they roleclaim a perfectly plausible role to explain the flavour text which listed Bluecoat."

Uh, No? I voted for Tennis Ace because he used a role to say "DON'T TRUST BLUECOAT", and then said he would vote for me, for following his advice.

You've voted for me a second day just because my posts don't seem to have enough daily input for you? Compared to the guy who has voted for no one and only post in pictures? Suuuure.

Tennis Ace · **Posted:** April 9th, 2014, 8:59 pm

Is there a reason you bolded my name, even though you have already voted or me? Mafia with two votes!

Sparky, I explained my AC360 message. It was me making up something on a gut instinct based on Day 1 posts, and one post at that. I really didn't have anything to go off of, but I didn't want to have a role and just never use it. Your second vote for me was AFTER I explained this. Ergo, there was no advice to follow at that point because I'd admitted that the message was baseless.

Also, there *will* be an AC360 message tonight. Stay tuned.

Muscular Ape · **Posted:** April 9th, 2014, 9:12 pm

What is the point of sending in your message once you have claimed it and explained it's simply a message you have chosen? Methinks there must be more to it.

Saten Ruiko · **Posted:** April 9th, 2014, 9:24 pm

Sighence wrote:

My first guess is Jaron. No way his role forces him to make comics. This way, he can be cryptic and still have plausible deniability. I don't buy it.

Dr Henry wrote:

Anyway, Sparky. Continuing my vote from yesterday. Contributing nothing other than a wild vote, as always.

Muscular Ape wrote:

I am pretty sure Thr is alluding to his strategy of 'fishing' out mafia that he used two games ago. Funnily enough, in that game, it also made him seem very much like scum to me. He is pretty much playing the same way as he was in that game, where he ended up being town, which is why I'm not feeling it at the moment. Am I missing a subtle distinction?

Tennis Ace wrote:

There was nothing I wanted to say after day 2, and now that I have revealed my role, I don't really see a point in doing anymore AC360 messages since everyone would know it is me.

Tennis Ace wrote:

Also, there *will* be an AC360 message tonight. Stay tuned.

Vote: Tennis Ace

Dr Henry · **Posted:** April 9th, 2014, 9:35 pm

SparkyAMS wrote:

Dr Henry wrote:

SparkyAMS wrote:

I figured AC360 was a daytime detective/reporter, turns out it was just a hypocritical Anderson Cooper imitator on twitter.

Of course Ace could just be lying, and it might just be flavor text. Either way that would make you someone I do not trust.

Tennis Ace

Also last trial Jaron claimed to be mafia all game, and was not. Now he is vicariously living through a Ninja Mafia Leader, so I am not certain he is mafia. But there is really no way to know.

So you completely ignore me... and then vote for somebody because they roleclaim a perfectly plausible role to explain the flavour text which listed Bluecoat.

Now just to put it out there - I do not believe Tennis Ace when he says that all his role can do is write flavour text... but I don't think a host would ever tell us not to trust someone unless a role pushed him to. The unnecessary role-claim is also suspicious, but my vote remains squarely on Sparky.

Yes, I obviously have COMPLETELY IGNORED YOU by making a post dedicated to why I voted for Bluecoat.

"and then vote for somebody because they roleclaim a perfectly plausible role to explain the flavour text which listed Bluecoat."

Uh, No? I voted for Tennis Ace because he used a role to say "DON'T TRUST BLUECOAT", and then said he would vote for me, for following his advice.

You've voted for me a second day just because my posts don't seem to have enough daily input for you? Compared to the guy who has voted for no one and only post in pictures? Suuuure.

1) If you just read that first quote back, it really isn't clear that the reason you voted for Bluecoat was because of that reasoning. It can easily be read as a random statement about Tennis Ace's role.

2) Now compare the reasoning you give for voting for Tennis in your first quote, and then the second. In the first, you just say you can't trust him after his roleclaim. The second, you actually provide a solid piece of evidence supporting your vote. I must have missed the part in the game where he said he would vote for you for following his advice and will go and look for that now.

3) Yes, that is why I have voted for you. If you actually take note of what is in Jaron's images, there are opinions there. Not very good ones, poorly expressed at times, but more than you had contributed other that bolding a name. Also, he just voted (Ninja'd). ALSO, after a few votes landed on you, you actually felt like contributing more and giving your reasoning for your vote. It is a marked improvement on your earlier posts.

Muscular Ape · **Posted:** April 9th, 2014, 9:39 pm

If we're playing that game, Jaron...

bluecoat wrote:

As for the quotes about believing Aragorn to be mafia and not voting for him, not voting is the second most useful thing mafia can do, the first being vote. And that's why it's always the guy who votes second.

Tennis Ace on Day 2 wrote:

Kikori

bluecoat on Day 2 wrote:

THIS DAY IS DEFICIENT IN VOTES. I work all day yesterday, forget to check the computer in the evening, work all day today, realize at 5 pm that I haven't checked mafia in two days, and COME BACK TO A WALL OF POINTLESS SPECULATION AND SHAMEFUL FINGERING. The only vote I see that I remotely agree with (other than my own, which I always agree with) is Tennis Ace's vote for Kikori. Seems plausible enough.

The last few games I've played have had few if any lynches, SO I, BLUECOAT, PLEDGE TO DO MY PART BY NOT DOING MY USUAL BULLSHIT OF ONLY VOTING ON TRAINS I START MYSELF.

You all can thank me by voting for Dr. Henry.

Upick Revengeance - GAME SET

Who is online