Hmm. I don't want to kill him just to kill. However, you make a good argument. If Dr. Henry is a vanilla, it would be smarter to kill him then Godders if Godders is the tracker. If Dr. Henry is right, we can just kill Godders next round, and if he's wrong, well then, we made a good choice on lynching him.

__________________
"The greatest thing you will ever learn is just to love and be loved in return." -Moulin Rouge

Is this where you reveal that you are a mafioso? Do you like arming us with reasoning to use to lynch you? There are so many ways this can backfire.

I already explained my stance earlier on and I was right. It took an extra day between for me to actually realize this, but my point stands. When votes were lingering between Sig and Market I argued against Sig on the grounds one of the two had to be mafia and all our other good reasoning du jour indicated Sig was it. I was wrong as to which of the two was the mafia. Then the next day, the whole Market/Godders nonsense kicked in. Let me be the first to say something rare in these games. I was wrong and followed obscured reasoning! Let's all go park our horses in their stalls now. Is that what you do with a horse? Park it? Do horses have parking breaks? You'd think for living in Wyoming I'd know these answers.

__________________
"I'm going to name you Ivana. That is a good reindeer name." - Robot Randy

Silly Squid! Us Wyomingites tip our horses. Its the only way to keep them from running off and stealing water from another horse's water trough, followed by a battle of epic horse proportions!

__________________
"The greatest thing you will ever learn is just to love and be loved in return." -Moulin Rouge

__________________



There are 10 types of people in the world, the ones that understand binary, and the ones that don't.

Thanks Lou for the help with the avatar.

I really hope that's not a "victory post" of some sort.

__________________

No it's not, it's just saying that we have entered the Zone that is Twilight, Not Day Time and Not Night Time, just Twilight.

__________________



There are 10 types of people in the world, the ones that understand binary, and the ones that don't.

Thanks Lou for the help with the avatar.

If i wanted to have a victory song, it would be "We are the Champions" - Queen

__________________



There are 10 types of people in the world, the ones that understand binary, and the ones that don't.

Thanks Lou for the help with the avatar.

__________________

Dr Henry.

__________________

JIMMY IMAGE FOR PRESIDENT!

Because if its not overkill, its underkill.

__________________

JIMMY IMAGE FOR PRESIDENT!

So Dr Henry could you just tell us if you're Mafia or not?

__________________

With 6/5 votes, it was very clear that the town wanted someone to pay for Topsummoner's death.

Dr Henry, Mafia Goon, has died a painful death.

Night 5 has begun.

__________________

Godders, Tracker, has died a bloody death.

Day 6 has begun. 7 people remain, so 4 votes to lynch.

__________________

Dat suspicion. Defend these scummy actions or die. As a rookie mafioso should, at the hands of righteousness.

SparkyAMS

Logic: There is absolutely zero reason to knowingly jump on a finished train unless it is to make yourself look more innocent.

Those on the DH train are as follows: Godders, Jack, Imasquid, Myself, Kisshoten, and (inconsequentially) SparkyAMS.

It should be noted that both Imasquid and Kisshoten had votes on Godders before all was said and done. Whether or not they are mafia remains to be seen, Imasquid's voting pattern leaves something to be desired still.

__________________

Awesome Squall sprite courtesy of Goten! Check here if you'd like a runescape or game-themed sprite!

So more analysis...Just in case anyone isn't deducing this on their own...

4) Aragorn Ix - Possible villager. NOT on Blue train, on market train, not on DH train. I believe at least 3/4 if not all of the mafia were on the bluecoat train. But, he looks bad for not voting/hammering DH. As he said he was going to place a vote, but never did.
6) Landerpurex - That's me, I can vouch for my own innocence. My actions also should speak for themselves.
8.) Jackstick - An enigma, has been on ALL trains. 2/3 being mafia. But he's plenty smart enough to bus the crap out of his own partners.
10) PhantomROse - grossly inactive. Was on the market train and bluecoat train. Tough read.
12) Imasquid - On blue train, not on market train, on DH train. Seems smart enough to bus DH, especially after I called him out for not voting on Market. Strong suspicion as mafia.
13) Kisshoten - Grossly inactive. Was only on DH train. tough read, but I doubt a mafioso would hammer one of their own. Tentative town.
14) SparkyAMS - Not on Blue train. On market train, on DH train (kind of). Looks less suspicious now that I compile the info, but his vote for DH is hard for me to stomach. Suspicion as mafia.

Unfortunately, there is no easy target here. There is NO ONE who was on the bluecoat train while also not being on either mafia train, which would be a dead giveaway. This leaves the person with the least consistent voting pattern (Imasquid) and the person with the most questionable vote (Sparky's vote on DH in twilight) as most suspicious, IMO.

I guess it all doesn't really amount to anything substantial, but that's what I think in a nutshell.

__________________

Awesome Squall sprite courtesy of Goten! Check here if you'd like a runescape or game-themed sprite!

__________________

At the moment, I have to say it is pretty tough on who to vote for, though Lander, you were also not on the Market train, but on the DH train. Yet you called him out for not being on the Market train, and you have a strong suspicion of him being mafia? That's the part I'm kind of questioning about.

__________________

Here's my view on the most suspicious players to me:

Kiss and Jack: Requesting someone to hammer is suspicious to me, and the ease with which Kiss accepted is worrying. That said, I don't think Jack is behaving like mafia and Kiss is new to the game.

Phantom: The longer this game goes on the more suspicious I become of her (mainly because of previous games). Jack, I don't think you answered my query on why you thought she was mafia earlier?

Sparky: Very suspicious for voting after the fact was settled, absolutely no reason to do it unless you're mafia as Lander commented.

@Lander: I said I was going to hear DH out before I voted. I heard him out and wasn't convinced enough by his or Godders arguments to place a vote on either of them (they did both lie after all).

I think the most likely mafia candidates are Sparky and Kiss, but seeing as you've prompted a response from Sparky, let's hear him out. I'll vote if I don't hear a satisfactory defence for either of their actions Day 5.

__________________
|Items and Monster Database Staff|Villager Writer|Guide Writer|
|Legend|
Gamestar is my twin

Hidden: 

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

I agree that this part stuck out to me yesterday, and I found it quite odd.

__________________

I have so-far tried to base my votes solely on data,


and as such I had and have been trying to compile a vote list to see who may be mafia.

Based on who voted for the innocent blue, (who I assume all to be guilty until proven innocent)
I made a list of who they voted for the next time. Out of the four of them, the majority was for Godders.
Thus believing him to be the only one on that lynch list to not be mafia,
I decided to place my bet on another train.
I believed the all-ready suspected Market to be over 75% chance of mafia, so I voted for him.

The only one who had voted for Market the round before was Top, and what happened to him after market died?
Removed from the picture.

Now following a 50% chance of Doc being mafia, I jumped on his train.
Hearing Jack offer Kiss the opportunity to hammer, I checked if she did.
However it was late and I only read the first line (stating not wanting to kill just to kill,)
I scrolled down to see if someone else had done the deed, because I did not notice that she did.
Of course right after I voted I noticed that she had in fact already secured the lynch, and that my vote was useless.
Not wanting to look wish-washy I kept my vote and tried to be humorous.

On a side note, the last person Top voted for was Market, and he died.
The last person Blue voted for was Imasquid , and he died.
The last person Godders voted for was Jack, and he died.

Also the people I had highest on my list before the last vote was Landers, and Imasquid,
and they are (surprise-suprise), the only two people who have voted for me.

That is all.

__________________

JIMMY IMAGE FOR PRESIDENT!