Today is April 16th at 2:42 AM, sir. We have another day of fun ahead of us.

I personally kind of find it hard to believe that a quote from "Mr X" comes without quotation marks already within his name. After all, quoting a post comes with the BBcode already filled out--you'd just need to edit the name to Mr X.
And yes, I'm now suspicious of you for failed BBcode when it should already have been properly done. FoS: Godders. Why don't I vote, though...? Two reasons. "Odd one out" is not as scummy in my eyes, to be honest. One mafia in a game of nine people? Unlikely. So what does that mean for us?

Achtung, baby. Let's rock!
Myself and my neighbor, Scar Sorry to oust you, bro. Riptide and Tahu--confirmed by the two. Monk and Henry, which I highly doubt anyone else would contest anymore. That leaves Godders, Rex, and Market.
But wait! There's a trend with day one posts in games and it's been growing a little more as of late. People are starting to tell the truth on day one! (<-Yay for one single mistake in my wording.) One trend I've noticed is that Godders is the only player who, before this recent wave of activity, had the mind to repeatedly discuss scenarios of being alone, or being a trio. Once again. FoS as the odd one out, Godders. That leaves Market and Rex as a pair.

Now, let's review. Who out of these four pairs has acted the scummiest, least interested in gathering information, most threatened by a listing of neighbors, and sought to tiptoe around any suspicions? Gee, I wonder!
Monk Basher. Dr Henry. You two are the mafia, with little room for doubt. A simple confirmation from Godders, Rex, OR Henry will leave you two as the last available, and the most suspicious. Your fears have come to pass; we know it's you. The only reason you could hope to behave this abnormally and keep from having a Red name upon your death would be something asinine like being Lovers. Go ahead, make the bluff. I'll call it.
I guarantee you, if I'm wrong about this, there's no mistaking this game has been figured out anyway. Then plan's already in motion, and you'll find out by Day Two.

As for Day One? We have two things and two things alone to worry about.
1.) Godders has a high potential to have lied about his neighbor existing.
2.) Monk and Henry are the scummiest players and the only who are logically not connected in a pair.
It just takes two more votes on Henry to see how well this has been figured out.

TL;DR? Monk and Henry are highly likely mafia. Godders is either paired with them or a standalone player, and a secondary priority. If I'm wrong about two of three of these players, it's not hard to figure out after that who it actually is.

Your thoughts, Henry?

Or that neighbors aren't actually properly paired. For example...
Monk -> Godders -> Henry -> Me -> Tahu -> Scar -> Monk

Kikori, you are actually entirely wrong.

I'm not Monk's neighbour. I'm technically Topsummoner's neighbour.

I was given the fun role of being the Survivor. My neighbour being killed off night zero means that I don't have the same win conditions as you, I just need to survive until the end.

But way to train me without waiting for a response guys, there are only 5 votes needed for a lynch and although I haven't got time to count, pretty sure you got there :/

...Actually, Godders, I think that might constitute cheating; you're not allowed to screenshot stuff that happened outside the thread. I would request that "Mr. X" rethink his decision (by elimination, either Monk or Henry if X even exists).

Well, Kikori's logic is good enough for me. Henry.

For the record, myself and Market are neighbors.

I'll save you all the trouble. I'm Godders's neighbor. I'm somewhat saddened you didn't figure that out by the writing style, Kik.

Now that you have your list kikori, what are you going to do with it?

Also, Godders.... Remember last game top hosted? The day ends when the host makes a post. All votes up to the post count.

Today is April 16th at 2:42 AM, sir. We have another day of fun ahead of us.

I personally kind of find it hard to believe that a quote from "Mr X" comes without quotation marks already within his name. After all, quoting a post comes with the BBcode already filled out--you'd just need to edit the name to Mr X.
And yes, I'm now suspicious of you for failed BBcode when it should already have been properly done. FoS: Godders. Why don't I vote, though...? Two reasons. "Odd one out" is not as scummy in my eyes, to be honest. One mafia in a game of nine people? Unlikely. So what does that mean for us?

Achtung, baby. Let's rock!
Myself and my neighbor, Scar Sorry to oust you, bro. Riptide and Tahu--confirmed by the two. Monk and Henry, which I highly doubt anyone else would contest anymore. That leaves Godders, Rex, and Market.
But wait! There's a trend with day one posts in games and it's been growing a little more as of late. People are starting to tell the truth on day one! (<-Yay for one single mistake in my wording.) One trend I've noticed is that Godders is the only player who, before this recent wave of activity, had the mind to repeatedly discuss scenarios of being alone, or being a trio. Once again. FoS as the odd one out, Godders. That leaves Market and Rex as a pair.

Now, let's review. Who out of these four pairs has acted the scummiest, least interested in gathering information, most threatened by a listing of neighbors, and sought to tiptoe around any suspicions? Gee, I wonder!
Monk Basher. Dr Henry. You two are the mafia, with little room for doubt. A simple confirmation from Godders, Rex, OR Henry will leave you two as the last available, and the most suspicious. Your fears have come to pass; we know it's you. The only reason you could hope to behave this abnormally and keep from having a Red name upon your death would be something asinine like being Lovers. Go ahead, make the bluff. I'll call it.
I guarantee you, if I'm wrong about this, there's no mistaking this game has been figured out anyway. Then plan's already in motion, and you'll find out by Day Two.

As for Day One? We have two things and two things alone to worry about.
1.) Godders has a high potential to have lied about his neighbor existing.
2.) Monk and Henry are the scummiest players and the only who are logically not connected in a pair.
It just takes two more votes on Henry to see how well this has been figured out.

TL;DR? Monk and Henry are highly likely mafia. Godders is either paired with them or a standalone player, and a secondary priority. If I'm wrong about two of three of these players, it's not hard to figure out after that who it actually is.

Your thoughts, Henry?

You're like Sherlock Holmes.

Sarcasm?

Unless you can discredit the logic? I doubt it.

As obvious a rolefish as possible: If you two have non-mafia roles, I suggest you come out with them now before an(other) error is made.

P.S. Godders.