U-Pick: Redux - Overpowered Village wins.

Tanksandguns · **Posted:** July 13th, 2011, 5:28 pm

Bad news. I killed Lander which means we have an inscribe mafia.

Sorry Lander.....

Tanksandguns · **Posted:** July 13th, 2011, 5:29 pm

And by inscribe I mean inactive. Stupid autocorrect.

Dr Henry · **Posted:** July 13th, 2011, 5:29 pm

Miscounted, there were 4 voted for Steely I think.

Monk and Tanks. One of those two is Mafia, I am sure of it. As it stands though, Commander Shepherd seems less likely to be a mafia role, it just DOESN'T (argue all you want about how names don't affect alignment, it just doesn't seem like it could lead to a mafia role right now) whereas Monk has some kind of role which makes him a jerk. (Jerkstick?) but to me, if a role says "talk like a jerk" it can't really have many good parts to it.

Dr Henry · **Posted:** July 13th, 2011, 5:30 pm

Tanksandguns wrote:

Bad news. I killed Lander which means we have an inscribe mafia.

Sorry Lander.....

Oh. Explain yourself. Now.

Tanksandguns · **Posted:** July 13th, 2011, 5:32 pm

Jack of All Trades type role and I had a gut instinct about Lander that didn't work out.

Sighence · **Posted:** July 13th, 2011, 10:04 pm

Dr Henry wrote:

Miscounted, there were 4 voted for Steely I think.

Monk and Tanks. One of those two is Mafia, I am sure of it. As it stands though, Commander Shepherd seems less likely to be a mafia role, it just DOESN'T (argue all you want about how names don't affect alignment, it just doesn't seem like it could lead to a mafia role right now) whereas Monk has some kind of role which makes him a jerk. (Jerkstick?) but to me, if a role says "talk like a jerk" it can't really have many good parts to it.

Maybe my role involves being a "bunny: cute little bunny rabbit that just wants to liveeeeeeee.

But you didn't think about that, did you?

You still think "Ohh! A bunny! Let's kill the :bunny:

!" But in reality I'm not even anywhere close to that awesome Monty Python incarnation.

Or am I?

You want me to be, don't you?

Topsummoner · **Posted:** July 13th, 2011, 10:12 pm

@ Henry

I voted for Steely as well.

-----

I'm going to be honest, I've been avoiding commenting on Tanks due to his somewhat annoying manner of speaking in his posts. I knew they were probably related to his role and felt that any argument against him based on that was not sufficient.

Anyways, I don't buy the 'inactive mafia' plea, nor have I liked Tanks focusing on Jackstick all game. Namely this post:

Tanksandguns wrote:

He hasn't been active all game. Very strange for Jackstick, no?

Which, simply basing on last game, is not strange at all for Jackstick.

Tanksandguns

On other orders of business, Jackstick, Ex Rex and Tru Ninja are being disappointingly inactive. If it weren't for Tanks' flat-out confession of killing Lander, I'd be looking at one of these three. Last game two of the mafia soared through the whole game barely posting at all.

Tanksandguns · **Posted:** July 13th, 2011, 11:35 pm

Yeah, because if I were mafia I would be one o the frat posts claiming I killed Lander. Good thinking. Also, yeah, it is weird for Jackstick to NOT HAVE POSTED IN DAYS on a mafia thread. So let's see.... Mafia don't make a kill, and Jackstick hasn't posted. Yeah... Jackstick with a major FoS on Top.

Tanksandguns · **Posted:** July 13th, 2011, 11:36 pm

First* not frat.

Tanksandguns · **Posted:** July 13th, 2011, 11:38 pm

And you yourself just posted that Jack was, "disappointingly inactive." Are you kidding me, Top?

bluecoat · **Posted:** July 14th, 2011, 12:02 am

It's a good thing I never acted on my Lander fos. Continuing voting for Jackstick for reasons Tanks has mentioned for me. If he actually did make that kill last night, then as he said, inactive mafia would equal Jack.

Dr Henry · **Posted:** July 14th, 2011, 2:41 am

bluecoat wrote:

It's a good thing I never acted on my Lander fos. Continuing voting for Jackstick for reasons Tanks has mentioned for me. If he actually did make that kill last night, then as he said, inactive mafia would equal Jack.

and if he didn't, he is mafia framing Jack and getting a wrong lynch today, coupled with a mafia kill, could leave us in a bad position.

No Monk, either you are a vicious Killer Rabbit or some other evil role.

Dr Henry · **Posted:** July 14th, 2011, 2:44 am

Tanksandguns wrote:

Jack of All Trades type role and I had a gut instinct about Lander that didn't work out.

And in all fairness, JoAT seems to fit with the role name, and doesn't seem like a mafia role.

What other abilities do you have and what have you used? (Have you detected anyone yet?)

Tanksandguns · **Posted:** July 14th, 2011, 3:32 am

I only have one other ability and thats to bring someone back from the dead. Obviously, I haven't used it yet.

Tru Ninja · **Posted:** July 14th, 2011, 5:17 am

Aren't

and

both seen as 'negative' emoticons? I know that the name you pick doesn't influence your alignment but it's something for the backburner.

It's now day 3 and Jackstick is really pushing his luck. Inactivity always kills town and unless anyone can think of a good reason not to, I don't see why he needs to stay around.

FoS on Ex Rex (though to be honest he's never active in any games, but even so it's not helpful in the slightest) and Tanks.

Giving up that information so willingly seemed a bit suspicious to me.

Dr Henry wrote:

So... long story short... I was right about Steely being mafia... and the mafia are killing off all the active people (Kikori, Lander) and i've been somewhat active in this game...I fear for my life.

Seems that the mafia tried killed Kikori because he was suspicious of Lander and me for voting for Steely. Probably to make us look like mafia. When that didn't work and we killed off Steely, they switched to Lander, who they quite rightly viewed as a bigger threat than me (he's played more than me and better in most games) and now I'm most likely going to be viewed as a mafia for surviving, or killed tonight as the next most active/good at working out mafia/trying in this game target left.

That said, the lack of willingness to vote for Steely yesterday, leading to a lynch only by deadline voting rather than a hammer-vote at the end, has left us with a condumdrum... at this point I'm willing to say that whoever else voted for Steely is 70% likely to be a mafia (me, Lander and someone else? I know 2/3 aren't mafia, so must be that other person) as they probably thought it'd be a secure vote.

So... who voted for Steely?

Another reason that it might have been them could be that they're generally seen as competent players and probably more of a threat to the Mafia.

tru :wink:

Topsummoner · **Posted:** July 14th, 2011, 1:06 pm

Not buying the Jack train, its sole basis is rooted in the idea that 'Jackstick usually isn't this inactive!' when last game he didn't the EXACT SAME THING... and was village. :\

And just because I don't find it unusual that Jack is inactive doesn't mean I can't be disappointed in his activity.

I'll unvote due to your 'bringing back from the dead' claim, (an ability you should probably use tonight lest the mafia attack you now), but until I see that in action I don't buy your innocence.

Now then, Tru came out of nowhere after several days of inactivity to bandwagon on Jack due to his inactivity... this is such a ridiculous act of hypocrisy.

Tru Ninja

@ Tru

If 'Inactivity always kills town', why were you yourself inactive for all of Day Three?

Unless you can think of a good reason not to, I don't see why you need to stay around.

Topsummoner · **Posted:** July 14th, 2011, 1:06 pm

he DID the last same thing, sorry.

Topsummoner · **Posted:** July 14th, 2011, 1:17 pm

double fail

he DID the EXACT same thing

Dr Henry · **Posted:** July 14th, 2011, 4:28 pm

Tanksandguns wrote:

I only have one other ability and thats to bring someone back from the dead. Obviously, I haven't used it yet.

You killed Lander. He is confirmed villager. Bring him back tonight or die.

Tanksandguns · **Posted:** July 14th, 2011, 6:07 pm

Dr Henry wrote:

Tanksandguns wrote:

I only have one other ability and thats to bring someone back from the dead. Obviously, I haven't used it yet.

You killed Lander. He is confirmed villager. Bring him back tonight or die.

That was the plan long before you even mentioned it.

U-Pick: Redux - Overpowered Village wins.

Who is online