You seem to be missing that every Detective ever investigates people off of Educated guesses.

My reasonings for my investigations are rather simple.

Night 1 - Myself - Insanity test.
Night 2 - Tweedy - Was a prevalent attacker Day 1 and 2. Stuck out as the most suspicious person for the time.
Night 3 - Monk Basher - He was posting all over the place Day 1, dropped off the face of the topic day two and three, very unlike him, and very suspicious. Was mafia.
Night 4 - Landerpurex - Slowly working through the list of people still alive, the bickering back and forth between Kikori kid is very frequent, but my gut told me something was off about him.
Night 5 - Defeat - You came in and were a very shady player overall, you rarely ever gave reason for votes, and always silently hopped on bandwagons, this stuck out as very suspicious to me.
Night 6 - Kikori Kid - Figured I might as well get rid of the last investigation that was unknown to me, since I figured the uncounter-claimed doctor would be attacked and thusly killed. Didn't want to waste an investigation on someone who would be confirmed by the host the following morning.

__________________

Defeat. What part of



Are you not understanding here?

__________________

Awesome Squall sprite courtesy of Goten! Check here if you'd like a runescape or game-themed sprite!

How do you know for sure it was mafia, and if it was how do you know a docter on the mafia's side didn't patch him up?

__________________

Hidden: 

oh, yeah, and I did NOT vote for jackstick?

__________________

Hidden: 

Scar confirmed it, and there has never ever been a Doctor on the Mafia's side.

I'm fairly certain that's not even a role that exists.

__________________

Because 3/4 mafia are dead, and no one showed any such role. I doubt the Godfather would have such a role as well. Assuming the only roles among the town are Doctor, paranoid gun owner, and detective, it would be incredibly unbalanced for Scar to give the mafia two roles, especially a doctor type role.

Also because, as said above, SCAR. CONFIRMED. THAT. IT. WAS. THE. MAFIA. THAT. ATTACKED. DRAGONCRUSHER1.

I highly doubt the mafia would try to pull such a scheme, and if they did, they would need a mafia doctor, which I doubt very much is the case.

EDIT: At this point, not voting Jack could have simply been to support your cover.

EDIT EDIT: DC just summarized my whole post. Oh well.

__________________

Awesome Squall sprite courtesy of Goten! Check here if you'd like a runescape or game-themed sprite!

OK then.
unvote

__________________

Hidden: 

I am somehow still alive. This is strange. So this means the the Godfather comes out innocent. WAY TO THROW A KNIFE-WRENCH IN THE GEARS.

Anyway, guys, there are four of us, one being mafia. What we should do today is no-lynch, someone will die tonight, I will protect DC, he will investigate me, find me innocent, and tomorrow we will have a 1/3 chance at victory instead of 1/4. Gonna have to look at scum tells tomorrow, because everyone will have been investigated. (Personally I see Defeat scummy for obvious reasons)

No-lynch

__________________

PenguinGuy. b/c you want a no-lynch this close to the end.

__________________

Hidden: 

AND JESUS CHRIST. nothing im doing is scummy. oh, hey, i was excited that the village might win...oh, hey, i didn't realize that scar had confirmed dc as a detective. I said it last game, and nobody believed me until it was to late (miscount that lynched me and whatnot), I AM A VILLAGER, and am new to this, and this being my second game, may make rookie mistakes, although I personally don't think I've done anything scummy.

AND HOW IS JUMPING ON THE MAFIA KILLING TRAIN SOMETHING A GODFATHER WOULD DO? HOW IS NOT VOTING ON ANY OF THE VILLAGERS WHO HAVE BEEN LYNCHED SOMETHING A GODFATHER WOULD DO?

LOOK AT THE FACTS PEOPLE. IM NOT SCUM.

__________________

Hidden: 

and DC...no-lynch right now is crazy. we vote penguin out, and if he's mafia, cool. we win. if he's not, you and lander can vote me out, or me and you can vote lander out, in which we win. I implore to vote penguin. WE WILL WIN.

__________________

Hidden: 

Except there's 4 of us, and if we mislynch that makes three. After the nightkill, there will only be one townie left, along with the last mafia. The mafia will overpower the townie, and we lose.

Rethink your logic there, nub.

__________________

Awesome Squall sprite courtesy of Goten! Check here if you'd like a runescape or game-themed sprite!

Is there a guarenteed night kill?!

__________________

Hidden: 

Pretty much, unless PG is telling the truth and he somehow saves the kill.

__________________

Awesome Squall sprite courtesy of Goten! Check here if you'd like a runescape or game-themed sprite!

so there doesn't have to be a certain mafia member w/ killing powers, they just have a kill per night?

__________________

Hidden: 

Yes.

__________________

Awesome Squall sprite courtesy of Goten! Check here if you'd like a runescape or game-themed sprite!

fffffffffffffffffffffffffffffuuuuuuuuuuuu
I did not know that. Well. It's a stand still, then......this blows.

__________________

Hidden: 

The fact that you would even bring that up, Lander, re-strengthens my belief that you are a villager. I still vote penguin.

__________________

Hidden: 

If you read my post you would have seen my reasoning behind it. Our chance at winning would go from 1/4 to 1/3, a significant improvement, and would also prove that the Godfather is found innocent and that we would then need to look for scum tells.

My vote stands.

__________________

Meh. That's just delaying the inevitable. Let's just assume that's what is going to happen and scum-tell now.

__________________

Hidden: