U-Pick: Redux - Overpowered Village wins.

bluecoat · **Posted:** July 15th, 2011, 1:30 am

Tru Ninja. I'm not buying that you're suddenly becoming active, 4 days into game. Also highly suspicious of a JoaT with only two powers. Nope nope nope.

Dr Henry · **Posted:** July 15th, 2011, 4:30 am

bluecoat wrote:

Tru Ninja. I'm not buying that you're suddenly becoming active, 4 days into game. Also highly suspicious of a JoaT with only two powers. Nope nope nope.

Not being overly defensive of Tanks until he brings back Lander... maybe he has another ability which he is keeping hidden for now :/

e.g. "if mafia attacks me when i use this ability, one of them dies" sort of thing.

Scar · **Posted:** July 15th, 2011, 8:29 am

Tru Ninja wrote:

It's now day 3 and Jackstick is really pushing his luck. Inactivity always kills town and unless anyone can think of a good reason not to, I don't see why he needs to stay around.

FoS on Ex Rex (though to be honest he's never active in any games, but even so it's not helpful in the slightest).

I'm sorry, are you really being so bold as to vote for someone and be suspicious of another for activity levels? Before you made that post I'm fairly certain Jack had been more active than you because he posted defending himself a bit on D3 I believe. Then in addition to those things, you give Ex Rex a bit of a pass by saying he's never active, when that is the same case for Jack.

It seems to me like you really just wanted to vote for Jackstick and tried to fluff up your reasoning as if he had done something legitimately suspicious.

Tru Ninja

Sighence · **Posted:** July 15th, 2011, 10:52 am

I'm not

, you

. It's appropriate, yes, but don't associate me with that :bunny:

bunny any more that you would that one nice doctor rabbit that always goes about associating us with :bunny:

carrots.

Also Tru Ninja for blatant hypocrisy and such.

Ex Rex · **Posted:** July 16th, 2011, 5:50 am

Sorry guys, I've been distracted IRL by vidja games (finally started playing my ps3) and have been out of town for a while. I've checked topic a couple times, but haven't really gathered any desire to post.

Tru Ninja, Y U SO HYPOCRITE@?@?@?
Also, he spent entire last game inactive then ended up being scum. Deja vu, anyone?

May as well claim my role, since I think I just hammered Tru...am Tyrion Lannister, double-voter.

Dr Henry · **Posted:** July 16th, 2011, 12:36 pm

Ex Rex wrote:

Sorry guys, I've been distracted IRL by vidja games (finally started playing my ps3) and have been out of town for a while. I've checked topic a couple times, but haven't really gathered any desire to post.

Tru Ninja, Y U SO HYPOCRITE@?@?@?
Also, he spent entire last game inactive then ended up being scum. Deja vu, anyone?

May as well claim my role, since I think I just hammered Tru...am Tyrion Lannister, double-voter.

Game of Thrones noob.

Tru Ninja · **Posted:** July 16th, 2011, 6:24 pm

Not sure if I'm dead yet or not but anyway, I am Tychus Findlay, and on lynch I can kill 1 player. You can bet your bottom dollar it's going to be whoever started this chain allowing the mafia to pile on and the rest of the villagers to decide it must be the right thing to do as everyone else is doing it.

I also have a night kill which it seems I won't get to use. Oh and I'm town, nice job.

Tanksandguns · **Posted:** July 16th, 2011, 8:26 pm

Dr Henry wrote:

bluecoat wrote:

Tru Ninja. I'm not buying that you're suddenly becoming active, 4 days into game. Also highly suspicious of a JoaT with only two powers. Nope nope nope.

Not being overly defensive of Tanks until he brings back Lander... maybe he has another ability which he is keeping hidden for now :/

e.g. "if mafia attacks me when i use this ability, one of them dies" sort of thing.

Topsummoner · **Posted:** July 17th, 2011, 4:29 pm

Tru Ninja wrote:

whoever started this chain

You should probably think this out more, because you'll be wasting your ability on me. Starting on a train based on an argument I whole-heartedly believed in is not 'allowing the mafia and sheep' to pile on, it's gunning for a lynch of a person I believed to be Mafia. Why would you use your ability on me, instead of Jackstick (who you are voting for), or someone you legitimately believe to be mafia?

I'll unvote due to your claim, but if Ex Rex isn't lying about his double-voting (which I doubt he would), then it won't do any good.

Tru Ninja · **Posted:** July 17th, 2011, 5:12 pm

Because while inactivity hurts the town, lynching villagers hurts it a hell of a lot more. Would you not agree?

Topsummoner · **Posted:** July 17th, 2011, 5:12 pm

I would agree, but on the other hand inactivity can be blamed on one person, the lynching of a villager is the responsibility of many.

Topsummoner · **Posted:** July 17th, 2011, 5:30 pm

It's ridiculous that I'm at this point when literally ONE person is suspicious of me, but I am Becquerel.

Once (automatically), I can avoid a nightkill. This doesn't apply to daytime roles like Tru's though.

Dr Henry · **Posted:** July 17th, 2011, 7:44 pm

Davesprite wrote:

It's ridiculous that I'm at this point when literally ONE person is suspicious of me, but I am Becquerel.

Once (automatically), I can avoid a nightkill. This doesn't apply to daytime roles like Tru's though.

Which can only be proved by... Tru actually using his role on you.

I'm not buying it. Seems like a mafia attempt to roleclaim to defend himself from ONE person's *possible* ability whilst appearing as villager as a result without having any serious scrutiny on him.

bluecoat · **Posted:** July 17th, 2011, 8:29 pm

Dr Henry wrote:

Davesprite wrote:

It's ridiculous that I'm at this point when literally ONE person is suspicious of me, but I am Becquerel.

Once (automatically), I can avoid a nightkill. This doesn't apply to daytime roles like Tru's though.

Which can only be proved by... Tru actually using his role on you.

I'm not buying it. Seems like a mafia attempt to roleclaim to defend himself from ONE person's *possible* ability whilst appearing as villager as a result without having any serious scrutiny on him.

This. Someone just hammer him and be done with it. Also suspicious of Top now too, so make that two people FoSing him. Slightly different reason though: Ex Rex declares his vote a double vote hammer. Makes sense that a mafia on the train would jump pretty quick to try and save him, assuming Animal doesn't go back and count the lynch.

Topsummoner · **Posted:** July 17th, 2011, 8:47 pm

Dr Henry wrote:

I'm not buying it. Seems like a mafia attempt to roleclaim to defend himself from ONE person's *possible* ability whilst appearing as villager as a result without having any serious scrutiny on him.

Was I supposed to stand by and let him shoot the wrong person?

If you had voted Tru first, and he said what he said to me, would you not be trying to defend yourself in any way?

Not to mention several other people have roleclaimed, one with even less pressure (Ex Rex).

bluecoat wrote:

[Also suspicious of Top now too, so make that two people FoSing him. Slightly different reason though: Ex Rex declares his vote a double vote hammer. Makes sense that a mafia on the train would jump pretty quick to try and save him, assuming Animal doesn't go back and count the lynch.

Huh? Can you better explain your reasoning here? I don't see how I'm at fault for jumping ship when he claims village and also claims he's going to kill me on his death.

Ex Rex · **Posted:** July 18th, 2011, 12:31 am

Where the hell is Onomol to save/ruin/end the day?

bluecoat · **Posted:** July 18th, 2011, 2:38 am

Davesprite wrote:

Dr Henry wrote:

bluecoat wrote:

Also suspicious of Top now too, so make that two people FoSing him. Slightly different reason though: Ex Rex declares his vote a double vote hammer. Makes sense that a mafia on the train would jump pretty quick to try and save him, assuming Animal doesn't go back and count the lynch.

Huh? Can you better explain your reasoning here? I don't see how I'm at fault for jumping ship when he claims village and also claims he's going to kill me on his death.

I'm not saying that you're at fault for jumping ship when he claims village. I'm saying you're jumping ship as soon as there's a risk your buddy might actually get lynched. All this is assuming that Tru is mafia, which if he is, I'm going to vote for you next.

Scar · **Posted:** July 18th, 2011, 8:02 am

Assuming this operates like past games, meaning when the votes needed is hit that person is dead regardless, then Top really didn't jump off when it looked like Tru might be lynched. He waited awhile after Ex had hammered Tru and Tru had threatened to kill him.

Topsummoner · **Posted:** July 18th, 2011, 9:11 am

Bluecoat, assuming Ex isn't lying, Tru is already dead. I'm really failing to see your point.

Dr Henry · **Posted:** July 18th, 2011, 12:23 pm

Davesprite wrote:

Bluecoat, assuming Ex isn't lying, Tru is already dead. I'm really failing to see your point.

The only real problem from Ex lying is that we do NOTHING for the rest of the day, assuming it is technically already over and, as we know, we have a CRAP HOST ¬¬ and we waste the day, giving mafia a free night.

U-Pick: Redux - Overpowered Village wins.

Who is online