I've already prodded, don't need to be told to do so by others...

__________________

Thank You For The Sig Stalesoul!

Hidden: 

http://img84.exs.cx/img84/8593/henryhero4rc.gif

Thanks henry!

__________________

Nobody's telling you to do anything.
Are you thinking about replacing him, Henry?

__________________

Hidden: 

Which reasons? The ones you never followed up on, or the ones you didn't think important enough to vote for me over The123king for?

Phantomrose

__________________

Goten is dead!

Meh. I'd still be voting for 123 if he was here to defend himself. I'm not Jester in this game though. X)
Care to explain your vote for Phantom? This can't be another vote and see what happens, as there's already a vote for her via Jaron.

__________________

Hidden: 

And this is a sufficient follow up to you...?

Can you find anything that doesn't scream "I'm a tremendously misdirecting mafia!" in her post?

__________________

Goten is dead!

Unvote Nish Well for now I have to hold on voting and sort things out.

I just saw The123King's actions from the day before as a little suspicious, as did some other people on here. Also Lander, I am interested to know why you also voted for me?

Unvote Nish, until things sort themselves out there. My FoS still stands, however. I am guessing Jaron's double voting is just joking. He seems to be joking a lot.

__________________

Sorry, did not read the previous posts right; only Jaron voted for me. Sorry guys!

__________________

I wasn't going to, no, but since you obviously have no intention of dropping it I suppose I can give you my take on it.

As a host I wouldn't take what I said as breaking the rules. The "no outside evidence" rule is for outside evidence, i.e., something outside the game that not everyone is privy to. If I recall correctly (and I might not as it didn't concern me), you were "ostracized" for "breaking perceived 'rules'" because of something you and Kik did with Role PMs? Like, Role PMs that only you can see? Aka outside the game? That's even the example given in the rule (which makes me cry foul at your calling mine a 'textbook example').

On the other hand, Nish's activity (or lack thereof) is very much inside the game. Not only can all of us see the he hasn't made a post, but for an active RuneVillager, it's unavoidable to know that he hasn't made a post in weeks. To come at me twice because of something every single player knows (read: NOT a select group of people) but apparently isn't allowed to voice seems rather harsh, especially when you already said you weren't going to be an ass about it.

So yeah no I don't think they're the same at all. There, it's addressed.^ This, among other things
And Kikori.

__________________


.

.Legendary themed months are back! Maybe.

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Well. I still think it's odd that you think it's odd that 123 said the same thing everyone else said and that there's apparently some mysterious difference in what he said that others did not. It was the only general opinion. There really wasn't much to go on at that point, and there still isn't even now. It really sucks that 123 got muted. I actually agree with Phantom as far as him possibly being a mafia muted by mafia. It seems pretty convenient. As far as what Phantom said about the black knife, yeah. I dunno about all that, but it doesn't seem like a suspicious enough comment to vote over. It seems to me she's thinking out loud.

Phantom, what are you talking about as far as the color of the knife goes? I don't recall a color being mentioned at either days beginning... nor in other games for that matter. It's a concept new to me, and I've played a few games. Are you saying that the mafia have yet to kill anyone because a knife hasn't been described as black? I'd re-think that if you are... flavor text is fleeting.

Kikiori, what exactly about her post do you find misleading other than the black knife mention? 123 may very well be a muted mafia, and Jaron may very well have been a failed mafia kill.

__________________

Hidden: 

1.) Why jump the gun on a lynch-an-inactive instead of follow up with a suspicion and vote for the latter?
2.) Why put the idea of a third faction via Serial Killer in the game before something more common or simple, like Vigilante or Jack of All Trades? Wouldn't this just cause more worry about needing more names lynched?
3.) When do two state-the-obvious possibilities that someone else had pointed out before count as "I'm a villager" thoughts? Not to discredit Phantomrose's effort to contribute, since activity is always nice and appreciated, but doesn't following along in that manner typically get seen as a Mafia trait?
4.) If she thinks 123king is a Mafia and isn't voting for Nish anymore, why isn't she voting for 123king now?

__________________

Goten is dead!

Would it make sense to vote for someone who is muted anyway? I do not see anyone else voting for The123King, but also think that it is a coincidence that he is muted...

As far as the colour of the knife. Correct me on this, but I believe I do remember the knife handle being described as black in a few previous games, or maybe my memory is fuzzy on that. Also, a lot of other people were jumping the gun to lynch an inactive before I jumped on it.

__________________

Um, no. A great example is Animal lurking. If someone sees that he isn't posting, but checks his online status and sees he has been on and perhaps even checking this forum, they could possibly determine he is lurking and therefor more likely to be scum. This is using outside evidence to make determinations within the game. Though your indiscretion this time really is of no consequence and is only the same as the abovementioned in spirit, it's the principle of the thing.

But since no one else cares, I have no choice but to move on.

__________________

Awesome Squall sprite courtesy of Goten! Check here if you'd like a runescape or game-themed sprite!

Thr why were you so quick to jump onto nish's inactivity train with so little input?
Just along for the ride on a quick, easy lynch?
After which, you unvoted and announced that you would be rather silent as you 'sorted things out'.
Slipping back into the shadows to hide, are you?

__________________

I didn't know you could replace an inactive player. On top of that the rest of the information that is to be gathered is to vague for me to make a solid choice . With that in mind I figured I would lay back and see if anyone slips up and gives ouf more information.

Oh ok. unvote.

Bluecoat
Your complete disregard of a serious inquiry irks me.

__________________

MarketMan

Your serious vote-jumping irks me.

__________________

Awesome Squall sprite courtesy of Goten! Check here if you'd like a runescape or game-themed sprite!

I am trying to drum up discussion. I was hoping bluecoat would look at 2 votes on him more seriously than just 1.

__________________

You'd be wrong on that one.

For the record, I kept my vote on Spiro because I didn't see any new evidence coming out at the time. And he still strikes me as mafia, so I ain't movin' that vote.

tl;dr I'm stubborn like that yo.

__________________

Interested in playing Dungeons and Dragons playtesting paper and pencil rpgs playing Dungeons and Dragons with your fellow villagers? Drop me Eadwulf me a pm!