Mafia 24: Day 7 - Game over (Mafia win)

Jackstick · **Posted:** April 29th, 2013, 10:24 pm

FriskyAlpaca

Dramatic bolding.

FriskyAlpaca · **Posted:** April 29th, 2013, 10:29 pm

Strong work Jack.

Jackstick · **Posted:** April 29th, 2013, 10:32 pm

FriskyAlpaca wrote:

Strong work Jack.

I do what I can.

SparkyAMS · **Posted:** April 29th, 2013, 10:34 pm

Being my first game, I wouldn't normally cast a vote this early on,

but when I saw Jackstick make such a distasteful joke so soon after PenguinGuys death,

without such as a hint of mourning for his fellow vilager,

I just knew I had to take action.

(p.s. imasquid, if you read this post in Robot Randys voice, it sounds so much better.)

Phantomrose · **Posted:** April 29th, 2013, 10:38 pm

Hmm, I agree with hearing the more quiet players speak up on this day. Let's remember though, not to waste the whole day, going back and forth on votes.

Jackstick · **Posted:** April 29th, 2013, 10:43 pm

Phantomrose O:)

wrote:

Hmm, I agree with hearing the more quiet players speak up on this day. Let's remember though, not to waste the whole day, going back and forth on votes.

Your contributions today have been extremely helpful. Thank you for unearthing these nuggets of wisdom.

imasquid · **Posted:** April 29th, 2013, 10:44 pm

SparkyAMS wrote:

Being my first game, I wouldn't normally cast a vote this early on,

but when I saw Jackstick make such a distasteful joke so soon after PenguinGuys death,

without such as a hint of mourning for his fellow vilager,

I just knew I had to take action.

(p.s. imasquid, if you read this post in Robot Randys voice, it sounds so much better.)

I drove a few of my staff members up the wall by answering questions for day or so while in a really dodgy Randy/Christopher Walken voice. Great detective work, Jack. If only I could put it all together myself! I am curious what you are hiding behind your humor. I know we still have two thirds of the day remaining, but it seems like we are going in circles. Also, Nicholas Sparks can convey only the emotional spectrum of a rock wearing lipstick. Or I guess that bear.

Phantomrose · **Posted:** April 29th, 2013, 10:46 pm

Thanks for the picture, Jackstick. It made me laugh a bit. As for Jackstick's joke, I just see it as Jackstick fooling around, being Jackstick.

FriskyAlpaca · **Posted:** April 29th, 2013, 10:47 pm

I would comment on Rose's play style, but I am deeply afraid of metagaming...

FriskyAlpaca · **Posted:** April 29th, 2013, 10:48 pm

imasquid wrote:

SparkyAMS wrote:

. Also, Nicholas Sparks can convey only the emotional spectrum of a rock wearing lipstick. Or I guess that bear.

Did you steal my Pet Rock collection? I was saving that.

Jackstick · **Posted:** April 29th, 2013, 10:53 pm

SparkyAMS wrote:

Being my first game, I wouldn't normally cast a vote this early on,

but when I saw Jackstick make such a distasteful joke so soon after PenguinGuys death,

without such as a hint of mourning for his fellow vilager,

I just knew I had to take action.

(p.s. imasquid, if you read this post in Robot Randys voice, it sounds so much better.)

I'm glad PenguinGuy is dead. Nothing pisses me off more than a flightless bird. I'd have killed him myself if it weren't for those meddling mafia.

I hope you're in hell, PenguinGuy. I hope you spend all of eternity looking for a cool patch of snow in the fires of hell.

Market Man6 · **Posted:** April 30th, 2013, 12:42 am

Topsummoner wrote:

I forgot how to play mafia.

Oh shucks. I liked when you chased after inactives.

I think I'm going to pick up some of tops slack.
scar where are you? 100 posts in, and only 1 is from you.

Dr Henry · **Posted:** April 30th, 2013, 7:41 am

FriskyAlpaca wrote:

Dr Henry wrote:

-sigh- is this Day One or something? Votes based on hunches, or just without any explanation at all given, metagaming, and Godders still being alive (which is rare past N1 recently)

As far as Godders is concerned... he is an idiot for thinking there were other roles, moreso for rolefishing, but I don't really see it as a Mafia trait right now, more just his own foolishness.

@Monk, have we? Had a lot of people fooled last game as Demon, how can you be so sure from a few posts under very little pressure than he definitely can't be scum? Bit of a weird statement that so would like some clarification.

At the moment, I would like more from Jackstick than a single vote in a post without any explanation. Multiple games he sits around messing about for the first few days, not contributing much when I KNOW he is a good enough player to have something more to add. If people want active, quick games, people will have to do more than place votes without reasoning and then disappear. Oh, and make jokes (see first post of D2) :/

1. Metagame
2. Will you step down off your horse and quit being a tool to everyone?
3. I only vote in hunches now because when I use logic or reason you guys either ignore it or give me Fuzzy Bunny

for thinking outside the box.
4. If you want to know about my hunch it has to do with ignoring the 3 D1 votes you had. Yeah, it is day one but you straight up ignored it, no snarky or wiseass remark. However, last game I FoS you and you draw immediate attention to.
5. Yeah, I metagamed....I suck

2) Excuse me? You want to explain how someone not reading the multiple clear host messages about a vanilla game, and coming out rolefishing, isn't stupid? Not exactly being a tool to everyone, why don't you stop being such a dick towards me.
3) Well if you only vote in hunches, I have nothing to really respond to.
4) Ignoring Day One votes? Are you being serious? Because they are DAY ONE VOTES. Thrown around all the time, I was not anywhere near a lynch, and if I had started acting all worried you'd still be voting for me for being 'overly worried over joke votes'. Last game, you FoSed me after I had voted for you, and since I was convinced that you were Demon (obviously I was wrong, it happens) such a move was something worth drawing attention to. If you recall, you were convinced I was mafia/demon yourself. Turns out the two of us were the best hopes in finding/destroying the Demon and needlessly spent half the game attacking each other. You can't have it both ways, you either get ignored by me because hunch votes are nothing to defend myself over, or even respond to... or I can start replying to all your petty attacks and you can start calling me a tool again. Which is rude and hypocritical.

@Phantom, exactly how many games have you played with Jackstick to be able to say that his joking around is nothing to worry about? He has been playing (quite well) in Legend's mafia for a long time, he is making the choice not to contribute anything useful and that doesn't sit right with me. How many mafia games end up with those mafia members being around, lurking, but not contributing anything so they pass by unnoticed? Ex Rex did it last game (can't fault me for clearing him as Godfather, I investigated him because my suspicions were correct, bleurgh), and he is not the only one.

Topsummoner · **Posted:** April 30th, 2013, 8:24 am

Jackstick plays like this every game regardless of his role, though.

Aragorn Ix · **Posted:** April 30th, 2013, 8:32 am

Jack hasn't played the way he used to in legends for some time though, DH. I don't think it's relevant to his allegiance.

FriskyAlpaca · **Posted:** April 30th, 2013, 8:33 am

It twas a petty post but it worked, just wanted a bit more out of ya. However, I still do not like how often everyone, not just you, calls people stupid or and idiot. Maybe Godders just skipped the header and signed up or forgot. No reason for namr calling.
Unvote Dr Henry
At this moment I am between Aragorn, Jack, and Rose. Rose for lurking, again, but could be her style/strat. Aragorn for the reasons blue devised, and Jack for sticking with the village idiot schtick. Neither helping nor hurting.

Dr Henry · **Posted:** April 30th, 2013, 8:48 am

FriskyAlpaca wrote:

It twas a petty post but it worked, just wanted a bit more out of ya. However, I still do not like how often everyone, not just you, calls people stupid or and idiot. Maybe Godders just skipped the header and signed up or forgot. No reason for namr calling.
Unvote Dr Henry
At this moment I am between Aragorn, Jack, and Rose. Rose for lurking, again, but could be her style/strat. Aragorn for the reasons blue devised, and Jack for sticking with the village idiot schtick. Neither helping nor hurting.

To be fair, I call my girlfriend stupid a lot :lol:

she doesn't like it.

Aragorn, I know he hasn't. Doesn't mean he has lost the ability to play like that, and inactivity in some games (not the last game though, but he was host) means that the more people contributing, the better. Ex Rex is the same, he HAS been active and played well in the past, but seems like he prefers to do nothing.

Rose is a massive lurker, who posts without adding very much of her own thoughtline. It is her style, wouldn't call it a strategy as such. At least she posts and makes an effort to be active!

Godders · **Posted:** April 30th, 2013, 10:31 am

I read just enough to know it was a Vanilla game, but not enough to read all the roles which were involved which is why on the sign up i signed up a minute after it opened (unsure if this counts as using outside information if its open to everyone to see).

Paidea · **Posted:** April 30th, 2013, 11:50 am

Effectively immediately, Landerpurex has replaced Scar.

bluecoat · **Posted:** April 30th, 2013, 12:05 pm

To play devil's advocate in the Rose discussion, active lurking has been her style the last few games... but then again, she's also been mafia/demon the last few games. Her not being out of character isn't necessarily evidence of her being villager.

Mafia 24: Day 7 - Game over (Mafia win)

Who is online